1. Prospects for common ground: introduction William N. Eskridge, Jr and Robin Fretwell Wilson; Part I. The Search for Common Ground: Framing the Dialogue: 2. Choosing among non-negotiated surrender, negotiated protection of liberty and equality, or learning and earning empathy Alan Brownstein; 3. Liberty and justice for all Douglas Laycock; 4. Belief and belonging: reconciling legal protections for religious liberty and LGBT youth Shannon Price Minter; 5. Religious freedom, civil rights, and sexuality: a Christian ethics perspective Dennis P. Hollinger; Part II. Guiding Principles for Mediating Conflicts: 6. Religious accommodation, and its limits, in a pluralist society Douglas NeJaime and Reva B. Siegel; 7. 'The Devil is in the details': on the central importance of distinguishing the truly public from the truly private in reconciling equality and religious liberty Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr; 8. Mutual tolerance and sensible exemptions Kent Greenawalt; 9. The joys of mutual contempt Andrew Koppelman; 10. From conflict to coexistence: the catholic response to the LGBT community Jeanine Gramick; 11. Implied-consent religious institutionalism: applications and limits Michael A. Helfand; Part III. The Demands of Faith: Perspectives from Select Faith Traditions: 12. Christian identity and religious liberty Leith Anderson; 13. The 'demands' of faith William E. Lori; 14. Toward collaboration: a perspective from the church of Jesus Christ of latter-day saints Elder Von G. Keetch; 15. Conscience claims in Islamic law: a case study Intisar A. Rabb; 16. Should an Amish baker sell a cake for a same-sex wedding? A letter on toleration of LGBT rights from anabaptists to evangelicals Jason R. Moyer; Part IV. Testing the Civil Rights Analogy: 17. The rhetoric of bigotry and conscience in battles over 'religious liberty v. LGBT rights' Linda C. McClain; 18. Against 'civil rights' simplism: how not to accommodate competing legal commitments Steven D. Smith; 19. Heterosexuals only: signs of the times? Louise Melling; 20. Conscience v. access and the morality of human rights, with particular reference to same-sex marriage Michael Perry; 21. On the uses of anti-Christian identity politics Marc DeGirolami; Part V. Strings Attached? Government Support of Religion and Religious Institutions: 22. Marriage equality, traditionalist churches, and tax exemptions William N. Eskridge, Jr; 23. Why money matters: LGBT rights and religious freedom K. Hollyn Hollman; 24. Freedom to serve: religious organizational freedom, LGBT rights, and the common good Thomas C. Berg; Part VI. Educational Institutions in the Age of Same-Sex Marriage: 25. Two paths: finding a way forward at covenantal universities Shirley V. Hoogstra, Shapri D. LoMaglio and Brad Cofford; 26. God and man and religious exemptions in the modern university B. Jessie Hill; Part VII. The Challenges of Public Accommodations: 27. Challenges to true fairness for all: how SOGI laws are unlike civil liberties and other nondiscrimination laws and how to craft better policy and get nondiscrimination laws right Ryan T. Anderson; 28. Dressmakers, bakers, and the equality of rights Michael W. McConnell; 29. It's not about the cake: against 'altaring' the public marketplace Jennifer C. Pizer; 30. Bathrooms and bakers: how sharing the public square is the key to a truce in the culture wars Robin Fretwell Wilson; Part VIII. Reflections from Advocates, Legislators, and Policymakers: 31. Sound nondiscrimination models and the need to protect LGBTQ people in federal law Sarah Warbelow; 32. Cultivating common ground: lessons from Utah for living with our differences J. Stuart Adams; 33. Shared spaces and brave gambles Michael O. Leavitt; Part IX: 34. Afterword David N. Saperstein; 35. Appendix of laws; Index.